Why What We Say About Rape is Relevant to Abortion

9 Feb

Georgia State Representative Bobby Franklin has introduced a bill that would re-classify rape victims as “accusers” until the accused was found guilty.

There is a lot to unpack here.

We do not, as a rule, say someone is a murder “accuser” until the accused has been found guilty of murder. They are a murder victim, and it is the job of the justice and legal system to find the person responsible and hold them accountable. We also do not refer to people who have been robbed as “accusers” until they determine who is guilty of the crime; they are victims of a robbery, whether the person who robbed them is ever found and convicted or not. The status of the person against whom the crime was perpetrated, in the legal system, has nothing to do with the status of the accused, who in every instance, including cases of rape, is indeed (or certainly should be), in the eyes of the legal system, only the accused, and innocent until proven guilty.

The law on the floor in Georgia would also apply to victims of stalking, harassment, and family violence. Is anyone else noting a trend, here? No, please, jump in if you think I’m crazy, by for those of you keeping score at home, I’m calling that 4 to 0 for crimes overwhelming committed by male-identified individuals against female-identified individuals. Fascinating, no? It is almost enough to make one suspect that this is not a coincidence.

This law would make the starting point for rape, harassment, domestic violence and stalking cases the victim. Once it is determined that those who come forward about these kinds of crime, already nearly impossible to prosecute, are themselves merely accusers, merely a person claiming something happened rather than a victim to be protected by the law, “I was raped” becomes a very different jumping off point than “I was robbed”, and not just because of the extreme and complex mental, emotional and physical toll. It becomes a different jumping off point because this law states, in effect, that the legal system is under no obligation to believe you. You come forward not as a victim, with every right to be heard and protected, but as an accuser, with a great deal to prove.

In many, many instances and places in this country, having been raped is a condition for being allowed to receive an abortion.

This law has the ability to greatly complicate already complicated access to a legal medical procedure.

Women’s access to a procedure they may need for any number of physical and mental reasons has been nearly inextricably linked over time and through policy to a vicious crime many people see as subjective and open to interpretation. This is intensely problematic, and as what I am rapidly coming to consider a full-out assault on women’s lives and bodies in this country continues at an inconceivable pace, the problematic nature of that legislation is becoming ever more obvious.

Under the best of circumstances not long ago, with a Democratic president and on-and-off Democratic majorities in the federal and state governments, pro-choice activists remained mostly quiet as abortion was categorized as something that should be “safe, legal, and rare”. Access was better, really, than it had ever been; it seemed not only unnecessary but possibly detrimental to rock the boat. But every concession made to what is commonly but I believe misguidedly categorized as “reason” simply creates a new line in the sand. We want to see that line as a compromise; people who are anti-choice simply see that as the new jumping off point for negotiations, and their negotiation tactics are increasingly more brutal. I believe what we are seeing here is a trend from “safe, legal, and rare” to “technically available and legal in certain places and rare” right on down to just plain “rare” straight through to “no”. And you would be hard-pressed to make me believe that it is a coincidence that every legislative initiative that seeks to define the parameters of women’s bodies’ experiences is linked.


3 Responses to “Why What We Say About Rape is Relevant to Abortion”

  1. Jameson February 10, 2011 at 4:51 am #

    The pro-liars have flat out declared war on women. Enough’s enough. It’s way past time we stood up to these bullies and told them “NO MORE!”

    Some of these scumbags got into power in 2010 by lying and saying their first priority was fixing the economy. But now what are they doing? Not working on job creation. Not trying to lower unemployment. They’re lashing out with bill after bill after bill to take away womens’ inherent rights as human beings. And even though some of these bills may seem destined to fail, the fact that they’re even trying to introduce such garbage is horrifying enough.

    How about we start drafting our own bills to take away some of THEIR bodily autonomy rights? Frankly, I’d like to see them get a nasty dose of their own poison. Think it’d make them realize that it’s a two-way street and they should have to live by the rules of their own hypocrisy for a change if those rules are supposed to be so good?

  2. Not Guilty February 10, 2011 at 8:51 am #

    Right now, American pro-choicers need to do a complete shift. The compromises and staying quiet hasn’t worked. Women are being failed by the pro-choice community because we are desperately trying to keep what we have. No more. The antis are ruthless so we need to be ruthless. Pro-choice needs positive propaganda and we need to stop apologizing because legislative crap like this should be where we draw the line.


  1. Tweets that mention Why What We Say About Rape is Relevant to Abortion | Abortion Gang -- Topsy.com - February 9, 2011

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Steph Herold, angryhippie, Emmily Bristol, Catherine, Kristin Brittain and others. Kristin Brittain said: RT @IAmDrTiller: new @abortiongang post: Why What We Say About Rape is Relevant to Abortion http://j.mp/egrIeY #prochoice […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: